Come Prima
$50-100Italian restaurantGluten-FreeVegetarian

Come Prima

β˜…4.5(100+ Google Reviews)Β·903 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021

Classy eatery presenting elevated Italian entrees & pastas with gluten-free options.

🍳Most Mentioned Dishes & Features

grilled octopus3 mentions
veal chop2 mentions
branzino2 mentions
helpful chef2 mentions
gluten free options2 mentions
orecchiette2 mentions

Vibe & Ambiance

ElegantLivelyUpscaleQuietIntimateCozyTrendy

Amenities

Full Bar

What Guests Are Saying

B

Brad Simmons

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

β€œCome Prima is one of those rare neighborhood gems that feels like it's been part of the Upper East Side forever, because it has, and thank goodness. The Italian food is genuinely some of the best in the area (in my opinion, the best). You can taste the pride and craft in every dish. Sal, the owner, sets the tone with his warmth, and Nina behind the bar is an absolute star, endlessly friendly, welcoming, and the kind of hospitality you just don't find everywhere anymore. The whole team makes you feel like you are walking into a friend's home. If I am being fair, the room could use a little more energy at times... but honestly, the quality of the food and the heart of the people more than make up for it. The menu from the chef is spot-on, comforting and elevated at the same time. A true Upper East Side staple and one I am always happy to return to.”

A

Arina K

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

β€œI confidently rate this place 5 stars! We're fortunate to have Come Prime nearby. They consistently serve healthy, simple meals that are full of flavor. The service is quick and friendly, the food is delicious, and the atmosphere is always warm and inviting!!! It's an ideal spot for a cozy dinner or celebrating your birthday.”

T

Thomas Troisi

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

β€œWe had lunch and what a great place great service abiance but the highlight was the food we had for appetizers shrimp with capers, black olives and tomatoes so delish main wast the cod fish with asparagus delightful and lite both a must such a wonderful experience yes we had coffee and dessert the usual but delicious as well”

Hours

Monday12-10 PM
Tuesday12-10 PM
Wednesday12-10 PM
Thursday12-10 PM
Friday12-10 PM
Saturday12-10 PM
Sunday12-9 PM
πŸ’¬

Discussions

Loading…

✏️ Start a Discussion
Loading threads…
Visit Website β†—View on Google Maps

Connect on Socials

✨ Review Sentiment

90%
Positive sentiment
across all reviews

Analyzed by NYC Dine using NLP on Google Maps reviews

Occasion Match

Date Night & Romance89%
Impress the In-Laws76%
Solo Dining67%
Business Lunch57%
Family Gathering50%

Location

903 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10021

Open in Maps β†—

Similar Spots