Island
$30-50New American restaurantGluten-FreeVegetarian

Island

β˜…4.2(100+ Google Reviews)Β·1305 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10128

A neighborhood spot serving seafood & American-style meats & pastas, with a yacht-club style decor.

🍳Most Mentioned Dishes & Features

curry chicken4 mentions
donut holes4 mentions
lobster roll5 mentions
lobster quesadillas2 mentions
popovers2 mentions
red snapper2 mentions

Vibe & Ambiance

ElegantUpscaleQuietCasualCozyTrendy

Amenities

Outdoor SeatingFull BarFireplace

What Guests Are Saying

G

Glenn DiResto

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

β€œWent with a few friends for a nice dinner. Started with a calamari and salad to share. Both were great. I had the sesame tuna and was cooked perfectly. Couple friends only had burgers but they really enjoyed them. The atmosphere was warm and cozy and server was friendly. Had the donut holes for desert and they were great. Hope to make it bck to try the swordfish or curry chicken.”

J

Juju Gurgel (SWFL Blogger)

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

β€œThis restaurant sits right on Madison Ave very close to Central Park. It is very cozy but super cute too. I arrived right Brunch and lunch time and even though they were a little bit busy and already had reservations booked, they still sat me and took great care of me. My server was Kate and she was very knowledgeable about their cuisine. As an appetizer they serve popovers with strawberry jelly. The popovers doesn't really taste like anything but the strawberry jelly more than compensates for it so be sure to eat them together. I order the scrambled eggs and it came with bacon, leafy greens, potatoes and multi grain bread. I loved the entire combination but their bacon was by far the best bacon I have ever had from any restaurant. Not sure if they smoke it and what they do, but it is delicious. I am so glad I went there for brunch, I received great service, the price was very fair and the food was also pretty tasty. #brunch”

S

Sara Silverman

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

β€œMy family loves this place for a nice casual meal. We always sit outside, which is nice for bringing our little one and pup. Staff is friendly as can be and accommodating. Food is always very good. Kids menu is a nice touch. Try the chimichuri beef, red snapper and the salads are all good. For non alcoholic try the detox. Really you can't go wrong!”

Hours

Monday11:30 AM-9:30 PM
Tuesday11:30 AM-9:30 PM
Wednesday11:30 AM-9:30 PM
Thursday11:30 AM-9:30 PM
Friday11:30 AM-9:30 PM
Saturday11 AM-11 PM
Sunday11 AM-9:30 PM
πŸ’¬

Discussions

Loading…

✏️ Start a Discussion
Loading threads…
Visit Website β†—Reserve a Table β†—View MenuView on Google Maps

Connect on Socials

✨ Review Sentiment

84%
Positive sentiment
across all reviews

Analyzed by NYC Dine using NLP on Google Maps reviews

Occasion Match

Date Night & Romance94%
Brunch Vibe89%
Family Gathering85%
Group Celebration63%
Solo Dining50%

Location

1305 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10128

Open in Maps β†—

Similar Spots